The Hidden Cost of Wall Street in Healthcare: Why Private Equity Must Stay Out of Medical Care

In the past decade, a quiet but profound transformation has reshaped America's healthcare landscape. Private equity firms have acquired nearly 8,000 medical facilities, from local doctor's offices to major hospitals, fundamentally altering how healthcare is delivered in our communities. While these Wall Street firms promise improved efficiency and modernization, the reality often tells a different story.

Consider this stark evolution: In 2000, private equity invested about $5 billion in healthcare. By 2018, that figure had exploded to $100 billion. Today, PE firms control approximately 11% of U.S. nursing homes, with their influence growing rapidly across all healthcare sectors. But what does this mean for patients and healthcare providers?

The case of U.S. Anesthesia Partners (USAP) in Colorado offers a troubling glimpse into private equity's impact. In less than a year, PE firm Welsh, Carson, Anderson & Stowe created Colorado's largest anesthesiology practice by acquiring local groups and securing contracts with two-thirds of the region's largest hospitals. The results? Price hikes of nearly 30% in the first year alone, and a mass exodus of experienced physicians – one-third of doctors left within three years, citing declining pay, grueling schedules, and loss of autonomy.

Even more concerning are the findings from nursing homes under PE ownership. A University of Pennsylvania study revealed a devastating pattern: PE-acquired facilities often cut cornerstone staff who provided basic patient care, instead increasing the use of antipsychotic medications to manage residents. The human cost was staggering – an estimated 20,000 additional deaths occurred in PE-owned nursing homes over a 12-year period.

Recent headlines highlight the instability this model can bring to essential healthcare services. In 2023, Envision Healthcare, a major PE-owned healthcare provider, filed for bankruptcy. More recently, Steward Health Care, a 33-hospital system under PE ownership, faced a crisis where vital medical equipment was repossessed, surgeons had to purchase their own instruments, and some facilities reduced patient meals to crackers.

The PE playbook in healthcare typically follows a familiar pattern: acquire medical practices, implement aggressive cost-cutting measures, maximize billing, and sell within 3-7 years for a profit. This short-term focus often conflicts with the long-term nature of healthcare delivery and patient relationships. Healthcare providers report feeling pressured to see more patients in less time, while complex billing practices drive up costs for patients and insurers alike.

Recent regulatory efforts have shown promise, with the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services requiring greater transparency in healthcare facility ownership and the Federal Trade Commission increasing scrutiny of healthcare mergers. The Biden administration's introduction of minimum staffing standards for nursing homes represented a step toward protecting vulnerable patients. However, with major political changes looming in 2025, the future of healthcare regulation remains uncertain. Many industry experts worry that existing oversight mechanisms could be weakened or dismantled, potentially accelerating private equity's expansion into healthcare.

These concerns are particularly acute given what health economist YashaSwini Singh has observed about PE firms being "sophisticated in finding and exploiting loopholes." Without robust and consistent regulatory frameworks, the challenge of protecting patient interests becomes even more daunting. The stakes are especially high for independent medical practices, which may face increased pressure to sell if regulatory protections erode.

For patients, the stakes couldn't be higher. When healthcare decisions are driven primarily by profit margins rather than medical necessity, quality of care inevitably suffers. The replacement of experienced staff with less costly alternatives, the pressure on physicians to increase patient loads, and the implementation of aggressive billing practices all contribute to a healthcare environment that prioritizes shareholder returns over patient outcomes.

The path forward requires a multi-faceted approach. First, we need stronger regulatory frameworks that ensure PE investments don't compromise patient care. Second, we must support and preserve independent medical practices that prioritize community health over quarterly profits. Finally, we need greater public awareness about the role of PE in healthcare, enabling patients and providers to make informed decisions about their healthcare choices.

The fundamental question we face is whether healthcare – a basic human need – should be subject to Wall Street's demand for rapid returns. As Paul Krugman noted years ago, "There are no examples of successful healthcare based on the principles of the free market." The growing presence of private equity in healthcare may be proving his point in ways we can't afford to ignore.

While private equity certainly could play a role in modernizing healthcare delivery, that role must be carefully balanced against the prime directive of medical care: putting patients first. As we continue to debate the future of healthcare in America, the impact of private equity ownership must be part of the conversation. Our health depends on it.

—--- 

Would you like some support? At Tracy Cherpeski International and Thriving Practice Community, we're committed to supporting independent healthcare practice owners in achieving extraordinary success without sacrificing well-being. Whether through educational resources like this blog, community support, or personalized guidance, we're here to help you on your journey to a more balanced, fulfilling career in healthcare practice ownership. Let’s talk! Click here to schedule your complimentary practice assessment strategy session.

About the Author

Tracy Cherpeski, MBA, MA, CPSC, is a business consultant, executive coach, and leadership development expert. Her mission is to unlock the potential for success in every individual and organization she works with. With a background in operations and a passion for driving growth, she approaches each engagement with professionalism and a keen eye for optimizing structures, processes, and productivity to boost profitability.

Tracy's coaching, consulting, and training programs are designed to provide a holistic experience, integrating leadership development, executive coaching, and mindset mastery. Her expertise has been sought after by small business owners, industry groups, networking organizations, government agencies, and corporations alike.

Originally hailing from the Pacific Northwest, Tracy now calls Chapel Hill, North Carolina, her home. Wherever she goes, her commitment to helping people and organizations reach their full potential remains unwavering.

Images by: Chris Li / Giorgio Trovato / Hush Naidoo Jade Photography